Illustrative Example
This story is based on typical security deposit disputes in Indianapolis. It illustrates common scenarios and outcomes under IC §32-31-3-9. It is not a real client case.
The Situation
This is an illustrative example based on typical security deposit disputes in Indianapolis. A renter signed a lease requiring a $1,800 security deposit for a unit with $850 monthly rent. Indiana Code §32-31-3-9 caps security deposits at one month's rent. The landlord collected $950 more than the legal maximum, creating a recoverable excess that the tenant pursued through small claims court.
What Happened
Pay $1,800 deposit under protest
The tenant needed housing and signed the lease, paying the $1,800 deposit. At the time, they did not know Indiana's deposit cap law. The payment was documented by bank record and lease terms clearly stating both the $850 monthly rent and the $1,800 deposit.
Research Indiana deposit cap law
The tenant discovered IC §32-31-3-9, which limits security deposits to one month's rent in Indiana. The legal maximum for this unit was $850, meaning $950 of the deposit was unlawfully collected. Indiana law allows tenants to recover unlawfully collected excess deposits.
Demand letter for excess deposit
After moving out, the tenant sent a certified demand letter citing IC §32-31-3-9, documenting the $850 monthly rent and the $1,800 deposit collected, and calculating the $950 excess. The letter demanded return of the excess deposit within 10 days, noting that collecting above the statutory cap is not only unenforceable but creates small claims liability.
Landlord disputes the cap interpretation
The landlord argued that the deposit cap applied only to apartment complexes, not single-family rentals. The tenant researched Indiana case law - IC §32-31-3-9 applies to all residential rental agreements in Indiana. The landlord's interpretation was incorrect.
File in Marion County Small Claims Court
The tenant filed a small claims petition for the $950 excess deposit. Indiana small claims courts handle deposit cap violations routinely and the statutory text is unambiguous. The filing fee was $95.
Court awards $950
The court entered judgment for $950 (the excess deposit) plus court costs. The landlord paid within 30 days. The original $850 legitimate deposit was returned separately through the standard move-out process.
The Outcome
Indiana's one-month deposit cap created a recoverable $950 excess that was not dependent on the condition of the unit at move-out. Cap violations are purely statutory - whether the tenant caused damage or not is irrelevant to recovering the unlawfully collected excess.
Key Lesson
Know your state's deposit cap - if your landlord charged more than one month's rent (in states with caps), you may be entitled to recover the excess independent of any damage disputes.
Apply This to Your Situation
If you are dealing with a similar situation in Indianapolis, find out what your landlord may owe you. Free analysis, 2 minutes.
Check My Indiana Deposit