I Received an Itemized Statement but the Charges Seem Wrong
Dispute within 30 days of receiving the itemization -- Start with Step 1 below.
Most important first step: Go through the itemization line by line
Step-by-Step Action Plan
Go through the itemization line by line
For each charge, ask these questions: Is it for actual damage or normal wear and tear? Is the amount reasonable compared to market rates? Is there supporting documentation (invoices, receipts)? Was the condition pre-existing? Mark each line as legitimate, questionable, or clearly invalid.
Request backup documentation for each charge
If the itemization does not include receipts, invoices, or photos, send a written request for this documentation. In many states, landlords must provide receipts for charges above a certain amount. Their inability to produce documentation weakens their position.
Tip: Use GetItBack's free tool to understand your state's documentation requirements for itemized deductions.
Compare charges to your move-in and move-out documentation
Pull your photos, video, and move-in checklist. For each disputed charge, compare the claimed damage to your documentation of the unit's condition at move-in and move-out. If your photos show a clean or undamaged condition, that evidence counters the charge.
Research whether amounts are reasonable
For repair or cleaning charges that seem inflated, look up market rates. Get an independent quote if possible. A charge of $500 for something that costs $100 at market rate is evidence of inflation. Document your research.
Write a detailed dispute letter addressing each contested charge
Send a formal written dispute. For each charge you contest, state specifically why it is not valid or why the amount is unreasonable. Attach your supporting documentation. Accept any charges you agree with to demonstrate good faith.
File in small claims if the dispute is not resolved
If the landlord does not respond reasonably to your dispute, file in small claims for the contested amount. Bring your organized evidence: the itemization, your dispute letter, your photos, and your market rate research. Courts handle these disputes regularly.
Frequently Asked Questions
What if the itemization looks professional but the charges are still inflated?
The presentation of an itemization does not make it accurate. Ask for the underlying invoices and receipts. A professional-looking document with inflated numbers is still disputable with the right evidence.
Can I dispute part of the charges and accept part?
Yes, and doing so is often the strongest approach. Accepting legitimate charges while specifically disputing invalid ones shows you are being reasonable, not just trying to avoid all responsibility. Courts view this favorably.
What if the landlord responds to my dispute by threatening to sue?
Do not be intimidated. You have the right to dispute invalid charges. If the landlord files in small claims, attend with your evidence. Their threat to sue does not make their charges legitimate.
How long do I have to dispute the itemization?
There is no universal deadline, but acting within 30 days of receiving the itemization is advisable. The sooner you dispute, the more credible your position. Waiting months to respond may be interpreted as acceptance.
Find Out What Your Local Landlord May Owe You.
Free analysis | Local law | 2 minutes
Check My Local Deposit (Free)