My Landlord Is Charging for Painting After I Lived There for Years
Dispute within 30 days of receiving itemization -- Start with Step 1 below.
Most important first step: Understand that repainting is usually normal wear and tear after a long tenancy
Step-by-Step Action Plan
Understand that repainting is usually normal wear and tear after a long tenancy
In most states, paint has a useful life of roughly 2 to 5 years. After a tenancy of 2 or more years, repainting the unit is considered a normal cost of returning the property to rentable condition, not a charge that can be passed to the tenant.
Determine the length of your tenancy and the age of the paint
How long did you live there? Was the unit freshly painted when you moved in, or was the paint already worn? The older the paint at move-in and the longer your tenancy, the harder it is for the landlord to justify a painting charge.
Tip: Use GetItBack's free tool to understand how your state treats painting charges in relation to tenancy length.
Identify whether the painting charge reflects actual damage or normal wear
Normal wear includes minor scuffs, fading, and small nail holes. Actual damage includes large holes, drawings or writing on walls, smoke staining, or unusual discoloration. Only actual damage beyond normal wear can be charged, and even then only the depreciated cost.
Request the painting invoice and documentation
Ask for the actual invoice from the painter, including the scope of work, hours, and cost. This tells you whether the landlord painted the entire unit or just touched up specific areas of damage. Full repaints after long tenancies are very hard to justify.
Write a dispute letter citing tenancy length and wear-and-tear rules
Challenge the painting charge in writing. Cite your tenancy length, the normal deterioration of paint over time, and your state's wear-and-tear standard. If the paint was already old at move-in, note that too. Demand removal or significant reduction of the charge.
File in small claims if the charge is not removed
Painting-after-long-tenancy claims are among the most commonly disputed and most frequently reversed in small claims court. Courts understand that paint does not last forever and that landlords cannot charge tenants for routine repainting.
Frequently Asked Questions
How long do I need to live somewhere before repainting is wear and tear?
Most courts treat repainting as wear and tear after 2 to 3 years of tenancy. Some states have specific rules or depreciation schedules. Even at shorter tenancies, if the paint was already worn at move-in, charging for repainting is harder to justify.
What if there are small nail holes from hanging pictures?
Small nail holes from hanging pictures are considered normal wear and tear in virtually all states. Landlords cannot charge for patching and repainting caused by normal picture hanging. Only unusually large or excessive holes may justify a charge.
What if the walls were damaged, not just worn?
Actual damage (large holes, graffiti, smoke staining) is different from normal wear. If genuine damage existed, the landlord may charge a reasonable amount. However, even for damage, depreciation applies: a 5-year-old paint job has limited remaining value.
What if I touched up paint myself before moving out?
If you made reasonable repairs before move-out, that reduces the landlord's justification for charging further. Document any repairs you made with photos taken before you returned the keys.
Find Out What Your Local Landlord May Owe You.
Free analysis | Local law | 2 minutes
Check My Local Deposit (Free)