Normal Wear and Tear: What New York Law Says

Normal wear and tear is legally protected in New York under New York GOL §7-108. Wear and tear refers to the natural deterioration of a property from ordinary use over time: faded paint, minor scuffs on walls, small nail holes from hanging pictures, carpet thinning from foot traffic. Your New York landlord cannot charge you for any of these. Deductions must be limited to actual damage beyond what's expected.

Tenant Tip

If your landlord charged you for items that reflect normal aging: touch-up paint, light carpet wear, minor scuffs, these deductions are very likely improper in New York. Document everything and check your eligibility for our free analysis.

This Type of Deduction Is Often Improper in New York

New York law under New York GOL §7-108 explicitly prohibits deductions for normal wear and tear. Normal Wear & Tear charges that reflect ordinary use are not allowed.

Security Deposit Deductions in New York

Quick Answer

Whether this deduction is valid in New York depends on your specific circumstances. Document thoroughly and get a free analysis.

New York landlords may only deduct from your security deposit for allowable costs: unpaid rent, actual damage beyond normal wear and tear, and other expenses explicitly permitted under your lease or New York GOL §7-108.

Tip

If you're unsure whether a deduction is legal, use our free analysis tool to check your situation against New York law.

Is your deduction charge legal?

Free analysis · New York law · 2 minutes

Check My New York Deposit (Free)

Itemization Required in New York

Regardless of whether a normal wear & tear deduction is valid, your New York landlord must provide a written itemized statement of all deductions within 14 days. Each line item must identify the specific charge and dollar amount. A vague entry like “normal wear & tear: $X” without further detail is generally insufficient under New York GOL §7-108. If the itemization was missing or untimely, the deduction may be invalid regardless of its merits.

How to Dispute a Normal Wear & Tear Charge in New York

1
Check the itemization
Did your landlord provide a written itemized statement within 14 days of move-out? If not, the deduction may be automatically invalid under New York GOL §7-108.
2
Gather your evidence
Compile your move-in and move-out photos, any written notes about the unit's condition, your lease, and any receipts. Timestamped photos are especially powerful.
3
Run a free analysis
Use our free tool to evaluate your claim. We check your New York normal wear & tear dispute against New York GOL §7-108, calculate any penalties, and generate a personalized demand letter.
4
Send a demand letter
A formal demand letter citing New York GOL §7-108 often resolves disputes before court. Our $19 package generates a personalized letter with your specific situation and the exact statute.
5
File in small claims if needed
New York small claims court handles disputes up to $10,000. No attorney required. Most deposit cases are heard within 4-8 weeks.

Legal Reference

Wear & Tear Protected

Primary StatuteNew York GOL §7-108

Penalty StatuteGOL §7-108(1-a)(e)

Questions

Common questions answered.

Your New York landlord has 14 days after your move-out date to return your security deposit along with an itemized statement of any deductions. This deadline is set by New York GOL §7-108.

If your landlord misses the 14-day deadline, they forfeit the right to withhold any portion of your deposit under GOL §7-108(1-a)(e), even deductions that might otherwise have been valid.

No. New York law under New York GOL §7-108 explicitly prohibits landlords from deducting for normal wear and tear. This includes faded paint, minor scuffs, small nail holes, and carpet thinning from regular use. Deductions must be for actual damage beyond what normal living causes.

Many normal wear & tear charges in New York are improper. If your landlord charged you for items that reflect normal aging: touch-up paint, light carpet wear, minor scuffs, these deductions are very likely improper in New York. Document everything and check your eligibility for our free analysis.

First, check whether the deduction appeared in a proper itemized statement provided within 14 days of move-out. If it did, evaluate whether the charge reflects actual damage beyond normal wear. If the itemization was late or missing, the deduction may be invalid regardless of its merits under New York GOL §7-108. Use our free analysis tool to check your specific situation.

Normal Wear and Tear: New York Deposit Deductions